Catawba Riverkeeper, Southern Environmental Law Center Efforts to Stop Duke Energy's Coal Ash Pollution of Mountain Island Lake Move to Federal Court
Suit filed in United States District Court in Charlotte on behalf of the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation; follows a suit brought in Mecklenburg County state court by North Carolina against Duke Energy
Two illegal discharge streams visible during low water. Both have metals exceeding N.C. groundwater standards. Stream on the right is French drain-diverted seepage from the 80-foot-high coal ash dikes. Left stream drains a seepage field.
This is the fifth filing and third lawsuit to be filed for contamination from Riverbend Steam Station's coal ash ponds. A summary is provided here, and the press release detailing the lawsuit is included below.
The first filing, at the end of March, was a 60-day Notice of Intent (NOI) to sue under the Clean Water Act, which was made by the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation and the Southern Environmental Law Center. During that 60-day notice, either the polluter can clean up their mess or the state can decide to file its own suit and take up the case for pollution it had not previously dealt with. That 60 days was almost up at the end of May, at which point CRF and SELC would have been able to file our own suit, but NC DENR did file the first of two lawsuit against Duke Energy, acknowledging the Riverbend ash ponds' extensive, threatening contamination.
Then last week, CRF and SELC filed to intervene in DENR's lawsuit that was filed in state court in Mecklenburg County. Finally, because DENR's lawsuits did not take up some of the pollution issues CRF and SELC had originally asserted, there were grounds on which we -- CRF and SELC -- could file our own lawsuit.
Contact us if you have any questions (firstname.lastname@example.org, email@example.com, our office 704-679-9494, or Sam at 704-651-5974).
Press Release from the Southern Environmental Law Center
CHARLOTTE, NC—The Southern Environmental Law Center has filed suit in Federal Court against Duke Energy for its pollution of Mountain Island Lake, the source of drinking water for over 750,000 people in the greater Charlotte area. The suit details how Duke Energy has discharged toxic metals and other harmful substances from coal ash in unlined lagoons into Mountain Island Lake, the Catawba River, and groundwater at its Riverbend facility for years, in violation of its water pollution elimination permit and state and federal laws.
This suit, filed in United States District Court in Charlotte on behalf of the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation, follows a suit brought in Mecklenburg County state court by North Carolina against Duke Energy. That suit was filed on May 24, in response to a 60-day Notice filed in March by the Southern Environmental Law Center and the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation setting out their intent to bring suit against Duke Energy for its illegal pollution of Mountain Island Lake.
The Federal Clean Water Act allows citizens to sue a polluter when the state has filed suit but has failed to enforce a standard or limitation that restricts water pollution. In the state court proceeding, North Carolina did not enforce a provision of Duke Energy’s water pollution elimination permit that forbids Duke Energy from allowing substances removed by its coal ash lagoons to enter groundwater or Mountain Island Lake. North Carolina also did not enforce the provisions of the permit and the Clean Water Act that prohibit coal ash pollution from the facility entering Mountain Island Lake through contaminated ground water.
“North Carolina has not sought to enforce two of the strongest legal grounds for stopping Duke Energy’s pollution of Mountain Island Lake,” said Frank Holleman, senior attorney for the Southern Environmental Law Center. “We have brought this suit to make sure that the people who drink the water from the Lake, live near the Lake, and enjoy the Lake have the strongest legal protection from Duke Energy’s pollution.”
In addition to the federal court lawsuit, on June 6 the Southern Environmental Law Center and the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation filed to intervene in North Carolina’s state court lawsuit, in order to ensure that enforcement action is fully prosecuted at the state level.
“The Catawba River and the communities that depend upon Mountain Island Lake deserve the strongest protection from toxic pollution of the region’s drinking water reservoir,” said Rick Gaskins, executive director of the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation.
Only a leaking 80-foot tall earthen berm on a peninsula into the lake separates millions of tons of coal ash in unlined lagoons from the drinking water reservoir. The berm is leaking numerous streams of contaminated water into the lake. In fact, Duke Energy even constructed channels to illegally assist some contaminated flows into the drinking water reservoir.
Monitoring data show Riverbend’s unlined lagoons have contaminated the groundwater at the site and flowing into Mountain Island Lake for years. The pollution includes arsenic, cobalt, boron, barium, strontium, manganese, zinc, and iron. Testing by the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation indicates that Duke Energy is discharging arsenic into Mountain Island Lake in concentrations at least twice the applicable standard, cobalt at 52 times the standard, manganese at 128 times the standard, and iron at 27 times the standard.
At its new Cliffside facility in Rutherford County, Duke Energy now stores coal ash in a dry state in double lined landfills. At Mountain Island Lake, the coal ash is stored in a wet state in unlined lagoons.
Downstream on the Catawba/Wateree River in South Carolina, a similar lawsuit by the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation and SELC against SCE&G for coal ash pollution in the Catawba/Wateree watershed was settled last year when the utility agreed to move all 2.4 million tons of coal ash from its unlined Wateree Station lagoons to be stored dry in a lined landfill.
About the Southern Environmental Law Center
The Southern Environmental Law Center is a regional nonprofit using the power of the law to protect the health and environment of the Southeast (Virginia, Tennessee, North and South Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama). Founded in 1986, SELC's team of more than 60 legal and policy experts represent more than 100 partner groups on issues of climate change and energy, air and water quality, forests, the coast and wetlands, transportation, and land use.
About the Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation
The Catawba Riverkeeper Foundation is a nonprofit organization with members in South and North Carolina that works to protect and restore the Catawba/Wateree River and its watershed.